The Phone Has Five Buttons and One Job: Compare Large-Button Phones by Memory Dial, Volume, and Who Can Reprogram It

The best phone on paper is the one your parent can pick up at 2am and reach you on without thinking. That is the test. Everything in this guide is about getting to that test before you buy, so you are not returning a box and starting over.

Local option: New Plan Care gives families in the St. Louis area in-home help so a parent can stay home: companionship, help with bathing and dressing, meals, and overnight care. Call (314) 405-0887.

Count the memory keys you actually need

Write down the numbers your parent calls most often: you, the primary doctor's office, the pharmacy, a neighbor, and the main family member. Count them. Then check how many one-touch memory keys each model offers, and whether the keys are labeled in a way your parent can read. Leave a spare key or two for the number that changes next year.

Test the volume and the ringer

Compare the maximum volume and whether the ringer can be set louder or to a different tone. If you can, test the phone in the room where your parent actually sits, with the television on, not in the store. Ask whether the speaker can be adjusted during a call, because the first call is the one that tells you whether the setting works.

Check the buttons and the display

Look at the key size, the spacing between keys, and the contrast of the screen. A key that is too small or too close to its neighbor creates wrong calls. A screen with strong contrast and large characters is easier to read in a dim hallway. Pick up each model and press the keys the way your parent would, with the hand they use.

Find out who can reprogram the numbers

This is the part most buyers skip, and it is the part that decides who ends up on the phone at 9pm. Ask each seller whether a family member can program the memory keys without the phone company, whether the setup needs an account, and what happens if the account owner is your parent who no longer remembers the password. Choose the model where you can change the numbers without a support call.

Compare the return and setup terms

Ask what the return window is, whether you can return an opened phone, and who pays shipping if it does not work. Ask whether the setup can be done in your home or whether you need to bring the device somewhere. These terms vary from seller to seller, so compare them the same way you compare the price.

Put the choice on paper

Write the model, the number of memory keys, the volume rating, the name of the person who can reprogram it, and the return terms on one page. Keep the page with the phone's manual. If the phone breaks next year, you will not need to remember what you liked about it.